One of my issues is that this series does not feel like it was designed to stand on its own two legs, but rather as a Mandalorian spin-off. The Mandalorian, Season 2.5 if you will.
Really, though, it doesn't feel like it was designed to stand in conjunction with
The Mandalorian either. As I said, it really seems like they didn't care enough about any of the actual Boba stuff to craft a meaningful narrative. At different points, it's seemed like there might be something they're going for, but then nothing really comes of it. It's seemed like different things meshed together, and sometimes an individual part might have something neat about it but, in the end, nothing holds weight. It's all pieces being moved around, mimicking the idea of a plot, with nothing really behind it.
It keeps saying things, paying lip service to ideas, but then not doing anything with that. He wants to lead through respect? How? Why? What does that look like? How does it impact how the world treats him? Even
just that could be a starting point.
Basically. But it also seems like they did a half-hearted effort at best at making Boba a main character.
Both to do anything with him as a character or to do a plot with him, and also the different themes that
could have been wrought of the character or plot but
weren't.
And they started actually working toward things with him in some projects, which could be built from here, but so far there really isn't anything of that.
And if they shove that unused
Clone Wars ending for his arc in here, that thing is going to feel
so unearned. Just moving pieces around.
He's too nice in the show. Mando is a better Boba Fett than Boba Fett. I wasn't expecting Boba to a straight villain but I was expecting someone who was a bit more callous and cutthroat.
One thing I really hoped they wouldn't do I'd make him too much goody-two-boots. Not that
he needed to be a villain at all, but he knows what business this is.
And he and Fennec should both know how much he keeps setting himself up for assassination, when he knows someone has already tried that and presumably will try again.
Boba was at his best in The Mandalorian, where he was just another badass character in Mandalorian armor. He's great as a side character. Not a main character.
I don't think it's even that he couldn't have his own story. I don't think they ever really cared to actually give him his own story.
As an example, take Fennec Shand. Disney seems to be trying very hard to make her a thing but don't seem willing to put in the legwork to make her an actual interesting character. Which might've worked if they stuck to occasional appearances (many popular Star Wars characters have become popular with even less character) but becomes kinda obvious when given a starring role in a show. Kinda similar to the show's namesake character in that regard
It's one of those things. Even she's somehow underutilized.
Really can't believe they gave Boba flashbacks and the best they could come up with was "how boba learn use stik"
To be fair, I do think there was supposed to be more received through that -- character, theme -- but it was constructed haphazardly and nothing actually comes through properly. It seems like there should be something there, and sometimes you can maybe almost see it, but then you get closer and it seems to have been a mirage in the desert.
For real, though, the flashbacks lead to the pacing of the show being all over the place, to the point where what is supposedly the main storyline has barely advanced at all(?) since it started.
As I said, I get the impression they never particularly cared about that storyline. It was just a piece they needed put in place for whatever plans they've concocted. The plot didn't merit trying to work it into a story.
I thought
The Mandalorian fell through in some different ways, and then this takes those and dials them up.