In my view, we are living in a golden age of gaming right now in terms of variety and, I would argue, quality (as well as the sheer quantity of video games out there).
(Never mind the Indie games that sometimes even reach the quality of a good AAA title.)
Hell, I'm in the same boat as you; I can't play every single cult classic or "hidden gem." Sure, I'll occasionally be experimental and even be pleasently surprised, but even then, I'm playing games based on gut feeling, that sense that I will enjoy it at some level, and I'm not going to play a game that I don't want to play just because others tell me to.
But yeah, I'm just preaching to the choir at this point so...
Tl;dr: I understand completely and don't hold it against you, haha