I'm sorry for a small OT, but I respectfully disagree. I don't see any glimpse of homophobia on this trailer. In fact, as a gay person that has gone through bullying and actual homophobia in school, family and other instances I find a bit dismissive calling "homophobia" the fact that the supposedly couples in a game are all "heterosexual". If we start calling homophobia anything that we don’t like or make us feel bad, the word will lose its true meaning, I don't think it's fine to trivialise real acts of homophobia with assertions like those, it hurts the real victims of this kind of hatred and it should not be mixed with our personal feelings.
About the "heteronormativity"... This is not a game like FE or Animal Crossing where you can change the world, create personal avatars, getting "married" or modify the story. In those cases I'm 100% with you that we should get as many options as possible so everyone can feel being represented on the screen. On a closed story/fantastic mythology there should be anything that the author seems fit, and I don't need to be "represented" to get immersed in, on the opposite, I want to travel to other worlds, evade myself and be anyone else. If there are gay characters, cool (and it'd be fantastic if done right in a no-clichéd way or just to fill a quota, but if it makes sense in the story they want to tell), but if there are none and there's no reason to be, it's fine too. I don't need Link to be gay in BOTW2 because we're in the XXI century and we are so advanced society and I'd love to be represented in the game.
(Not my intention, again, to offence anyone with my opinion. Just let's not get ahead of ourselves with the "couples" on XC3, most probably is just some Animus/Anima thing or other pseudo-biologic-scientific-religious subplot like the need to get some complete genome from the two complementary sexes/core crystals).
.
.
.
.
Back on Topic!! Some people heard some musical influences from XC1 and XC2 on the trailer... Do you think there will be many "mix" or inspired or evolved themes from the old games or it'll be mostly new compositions with just some nice touches/motifs here and there? I'm hoping for the latter, I want the composers to outdid themselves and be creative.
I agree with your general position here, but you’ve entirely misrepresented what I said to the point of discomfort in my end. I don’t quite feel comfortable even continuing here as the crowd has clearly spoken with the reactions to your post and views me in an incorrect light / I don’t want to continue OT, but I will try to course correct…
I did
not say anything in this trailer was homophobic. I said that a default assumption to pair man and woman
could be
rooted in heteronormativity or homophobia. As a queer person, it sucks to see
so many pairings of couples just so happen to all be man and woman. Could a decision like that have been made without thought to the alternative and been harmless? Absolutely! That’s what usually happens in these cases. Roots run deep and through generations, that’s the danger of a status quo.
Side note: to those (including yourself) politely pointing out the animus / anima background – thanks! Again, I don’t know a lot about the series and never claimed to. I shared my opinion hoping to be educated more by fans of it, which happened, so yay. Furthermore, I shared my opinion at this stage and eagerly awaited learning more about the pairing mechanic (eg. if there even are romantic undertones to it, though if there are not it makes it the limitation all the more silly).
All I said in my follow up is that intent isn’t impact. The background to the decision helps explain things, but it doesn’t make me feel any less “othered” so I was just noting that. The importance of representation is that it helps undo the idea of a “standard”. As noted, I too am a queer person who has gone through their fair share of ~it all~, and so I like to see the media I consume do better. I personally hold this standard for all media I consume when appropriate- tho ofc I’m not always a fair or consistent critic, who is. I am however quite uncomfortable that you’re telling me not to mix my feelings when I am speaking on personal experience– my feelings are valid. I shared my single opinion and you extended it to something much larger. I made no claim that it would be wrong to support this game or that the developers have done something wrong, I just personally don’t love it. I would take away the word homophobia looking back on my message as I understand that seems to have been interpreted as an
act and heteronormativity already did the job, but it
is a noun and something that exists on many, many levels
To your second point - I feel like I’m just going to state the obvious but to be complete, yes, of course this isn’t a sim game. And no, I don’t expect every title to have gay representation. You’re delving into whataboutism here and further generalizing + misrepresenting my point. I agree with your views laid out there, period.
Anyhow, I hope this helps resolve some of the disconnect here. I understand that you felt dismissed by my post and I’m sorry for that. Likewise I’m rather flustered by this all and the silent majority staring down at me lol, but I really do appreciate you taking the time to engage productively and hope this clears things up.
Whew that was more than I intended to say, but I’d like to go to sleep so I’m leaving it as is lol.