Just finished the game so I'm going to write my thoughts.
Before that tho, I just want to say that I saw the picture of Rex with Pyra, Mythra and Nia as his wives before release and thought it was a fanart. Can't believe it was actually real. Rex gets a harem. It's canon. and It's implied he gets all three kids at the same time. Funniest shit i've seen today.
Anyway, my thoughts.
GAMEPLAY: this is the best in the series, I don't think anyone will disagree with that. I do have some nitpicks. First is the chain attacks which are too reliable and easy. I prefer the ones in 2 because they felt earned and you had to make them good enough to actually be effective. Here you just have to wait for them and then do decently and you can kill everything except UM and bosses. Makes the game too easy (played on normal, so it might change on higher difficulties).Also some heroes bonuses like Ashera are just broken.
Second nitpick is That you can't use a full set of Agnus skill in the fusion arts. it has to be from one side or the other.
Third is no stutter stepping. I miss it, it made everything soo much faster.
Other than that it's pretty damn great.
AREAS AND LEVEL DESIGN: They are pretty damn good and very pretty, but I haven't gone wow with most of them like I did with Valack mountain and Eryth Sea in XC1 or almost every area in XC2. Best loocking ones were probably Upper Aetia and that one colony where Nimue is. Colonies and the city are dissapointing, with the former being too similar with each other and the latter just kinda boring. Not sure if I would rank them above XC1 or not, might have to replay the game.
MUSIC: It's fantastic, I will say that the region themes are probably the weakest. I still need to fully listen to them without being interrupted, so my opinion on that might change. Not sure if I would put it above 2's soundtrack, but let's see after I listen more to it
CHARACTERS: Main party is great. The relationship with each other is great and they are all very likeable. I wouldn't say they are as strong as the characters in XC2 due to them not growing as much compared to the beginning of the game except in the relationship with each other. Most of their growth already happened before the story and it's only shown in flasbacks, which is dissapointing. Sena kinda gets the short end of the stick. The chapter where it seems like she will be the protagonist gets interrupted by other events and her ascension quest focuses mostly on Gonshor and Shania's relationship. But they are still good.
Won't talk about Side caracters as I still need to do the ascension quests for all of them. However I do wish characters like Ethel, Cammuravi and Isurd were more involved in the story, but unfortunately they are not. Ghondor is great tho
Villains are just bad. Most of them are just evil to be evil and remain largely unexplained. D in particular is dissapointing. could have been this constant presence like Metal Face or Malos, but instead he gets revealed to be just another evil guy like the other 20 mobius you fought until now, just crazier.
Still deciding on N, but I will say that how his story ends is kinda abrubt.
Then there's Z. I still need to decide whether the explanation of who he, X and Y are is good or not (leaning more on the latter) but he largely remains dissapointing due to how little he interacts with the main cast.
STORY: This is probably the weakest element in the game aside from the villains. It's good, but it's the weakest in the trilogy, mainly due to the villains and how much remains unexplained and some unsatisfying momemts. too many questions are left unanswered and the questions that do get answered mostly get a dissapointing one. Starts of strong, peaks at Chapter 5 but then quality goes down, with chapter 6 just being bad. It probably needed an extra chapter or get a full 10 chapters to complete it and make it great.
One thing thaat's both funny and sad is how this is probably the most serious in the trilogy but ends up feeling the most classic shonen out of the three and the less dark one.
Another thing That I didn't like was how some characters realization are done. Most of them felt like this
Character: My life sucks and I hate the world because of this thing
Noah: Your life doesn't suck, the world is good and you're wrong about that thing, it actually means this
Character: Gasp you're right!
which is just one of the most boring shonen things there are and makes everyone else feel like an idiot.
Thankfully the ending is good but bittersweet. I'll admit that I would have liked to see the world and characters be together from now on. but this is fine.
But yeah, those unanswered questions and the dissapointing answers + the boring villains hurt the story.
Some changes I would make to the story:
- either don't kill Mio in Chapter 5 or don't bring her back so soon or at all. End of chapter 5 was great, but it's ruined by what happens during the beginning of chapter 6.
- A bigger sense of unrgency in the story. Mio having only 3 months was great. It made it feel like you needed to find a solution as fas as possible otherwise she dies. Instead everything get's better in chapter 6 and Mio won't die soon anymore. Would have liked to see the party trying to accept her death, before finding her as another puppet of Y and trying to make her remember who she was.
- Just go full in on the XC1/2 connections. Trying to keep it as beginner friendly as possible hurt it imo
- Make the MCs side stories part of the actual story. Only Noah and Mio's ascension quests are part of the story, why not the others.
I would have liked to see the story set in the world the moment they fused and something was about to destroy them both, so you tried to both find a way to stop the destruction and unite the different worlds who were in chaos.
Other smaller complaints.
- Coins are useless. I'm pretty sure I'm a millionaire in game. Most of the Items you can buy feel useless so there's no need to spend anything.
- having to kill a buch of enemies to liberate a ferronis hulk is just annoying. Would have prefered if there was like a quest involved with them.
- I miss Heart2Hearts.
- X and Y not having a cutscene as they die is dissapointing
- Don't like how the "follow leader" command makes everyone stop fighting until you remove it
- Holding A to stop fighting. even during the final boss I had moments where I stopped fighting because I was trying to revive a character.
- Game is a bit easy.
- sometimes it throws at you boss after boss. Having six fights between chapter 5 and six was too much
- Pacing problems. some chapters are too long (like chapter 4) or things slow down to a crawl, like half of chapter 7 being a fetch quest.
- I'm sad Poppi was alive but not involved at all.
Overall, I really like the game. I still prefer XC2 due to the story, characters and setting, but I like 3 more than 1.
My ranking of the games would be
- XC2
- XC3
- XCDE
- XCX
Now we wait for the DLC. Hoping it will be great storywise.
But yeah, after all this, I can say this has truly been the Xenoblade Chronicles 3