• Hey everyone, staff have documented a list of banned content and subject matter that we feel are not consistent with site values, and don't make sense to host discussion of on Famiboards. This list (and the relevant reasoning per item) is viewable here.

Reviews Super Mario Bros. Wonder: Review Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lugia667

Inkling
Pronouns
He/Him
3iXBRmO.jpg


Current Reviews:

93 Metacritic
92 OpenCritic

IGN 9/10

Super Mario Bros. Wonder looks and plays like the true next step for 2D Mario platformers that it aims to be. The Wonder effects change each stage in both surprising and delightful ways, and the Flower Kingdom makes for a vibrant and refreshing change of pace from the Mushroom Kingdom. With apologies to Yoshi's Island, Wonder feels like a proper 21st-century follow-up to Super Mario World.

Gamespot 9/10

Super Mario Bros. Wonder is a bold choice for a name. It plants a flag in the ground that suggests anything less than a constant sense of awe and delight will be a failure by its own terms. But then, surprisingly, Mario Wonder rises to the challenge and the result is a modern classic. The Wonder effects are the marquee feature, and for good reason, as they serve as a springboard for a cornucopia of creativity. But it's the smart and thoughtful choices around new power-ups, badges, online multiplayer, and visual flair that cement it in Mario canon. This is the rightful successor to Super Mario World, and hopefully, will serve as a touchstone for 2D Mario going forward.

Nintendolife 9/10
Super Mario Bros. Wonder is, quite simply, the best 2D Mario game since Super Mario World. This is the slickest, sharpest, and smartest that two-dimensional Mario has felt since 1991 and in its Wonder Flowers, badges, and online aspects, it serves up an endlessly inventive and impressive platforming adventure that we've been utterly hooked on. With local co-op and online fun adding to the replayability factor and nigh-on perfect performance in both docked and handheld modes, this feels like 2D Mario with its mojo back, and one of the very best platformers we've played in quite some time.

Eurogamer 5/5

It's a rush. Whenever I tell someone I'm playing the new Mario, they ask what the angle is. Is it space, like Galaxy? Vacations like Sunshine? Is it retro stuff like New Super Mario Bros? Is it coins like New Super Mario Bros 2? Is it just really, really hardcore, like New Super Mario Bros U?

The answer, I think, is that there is no one angle. There's elephants and flowers and that hidden event that splits every level in half, but none of those these add up to an angle. In truth, the angle here is that every level is its own angle, and each angle has these little sub-angels, throwaway gimmicks, one-shot animations, bespoke enemies. They called it Super Mario Bros. Wonder. They could just as easily have called it Super Mario Bros. Imagination. Jeepers.

Metro 10/10

Ultimately, the only real flaw with Super Mario Bros. Wonder is that at one point it will end (there's plenty of post-game content though and it's highly replayable, especially in multiplayer). It absolutely deserves to be talked about in the same breath as Super Mario Bros. 3 and Super Mario World and is a stunning achievement of imagination, perfectly hewn gameplay mechanics, and good old fashioned Nintendo surrealism.

Despite being the latest entry in an almost 40-year-old franchise its greatest achievement is that you never know what's going to happen next… and are always charmed and amazed when you find out. Super Mario Bros. Wonder is an absolute joy, from beginning to end, and one of the best things Nintendo has ever done.

Comicbook 10/10

Super Mario Bros. Wonder is about as close to perfection as it gets for a 2D Mario game. While the New Super Mario Bros. games were fun, they never felt like they had their own distinct identity, the way we saw with classic Mario games like Super Mario Bros. 3 or Super Mario World. Super Mario Bros. Wonder is dripping with creativity and personality in every facet.

CG Magazine 10/10

Back in 2017, I said that Super Mario Odyssey was the best 3D Mario Nintendo had ever made—reimagining familiar concepts in such a new and creative way that it set the new standard for how to design 3D Mario. Now, Nintendo has done the same for 2D Mario, reinvigorating the iconic side-scroller while maintaining everything that made the games so incredibly fun and memorable. Since I started playing it for review, I haven't been able to put it down, and I can see myself going back to it as regularly as I do Super Mario World or Super Mario 3.

Feel free to add any reviews btw
 
Last edited:
Damn I got super happy when I saw that 94!!!
When I clicked tho it dropped to 93. Hope it get back to 94 tho, the game really deserves that!!

Crazy how Nintendo might end up having 2 94s and 1 96 this year. Not to mention one 92 and another possible 90+ with RPG.

Talent won!!!
 
this is the best review imo feels like how I will feel about the game

80
Dexerto
OCT 17, 2023
While Super Mario Bros. Wonder doesn't revolutionize Nintendo’s beloved series, the charming 2D platformer successfully pays homage to its roots, paving the way forward with unique twists that keep the gameplay feeling fresh…Mario Bros. Wonder may not take the crown from Super Mario Bros. 3 or Odyssey, but the latest outing encapsulates the very essence of what a 2D Mario game should be. It’s silly, whacky, and most importantly great fun…The fact that Nintendo can still deliver a great 2D Mario game 42 years after the first title hit our screens back in 1981, really is a wonder in itself.
 
And now imagine the score if they would've gone with Chris Pratt and Jack Black for dubbing the game!
 
Those reviews are great. So many ‘they promised endless imagination on the box and they delivered’ vibes
 
oh my god it's back at 94, the mario C team has done it again. I thought they might have flopped by making a 93 metacritic scored game but instead they beat the odds with an outstanding 94 on metacritic. They've put Chris Dring in shame.
 
Yup, if you enabled Wired Controller Communication in the settings there's more input lag. Especially noticeable in games that use gyro like Splatoon.

Do they have fan servers for this stuff? I know there are ways to get mystery gifts and DQ9 quests over servers, but not sure it works the same way on the system end.

Is this the best the C team can do?

False alarm, it's just a 93 on metacritic now. Nothing special tbh. It really was just a C team effort.

You can't have A listers working in a C team, it wouldn't make any sense

C+.

You know, you can't shake up the rankings this easily.

It‘s a C-Team game after all. Can‘t be that good.

This was about expected, there was no way that the C-Team would make a good game.
Lmao. This will follow Dring for years to come 😂
 
Looks like both Wonder and Spidey are reviewing well... im gonna be busy this weekend lol.

Sonic looks good but unfortunately is releasing the same week as a bigger 2D game
 
0
Happy to hear that many like it, but it is pretty funny to see people lose their shit over the game going down and up a single percent.
Damn, and here I was hoping I'd hold out. Nope, really want to play it
 
Seems I had no reason to play it safe with high 80s in the prediction thread. Easily broke the 90s!

Metroid Prime, TOTK, Pikmin 4, Mario Wonder. What a great end to the Switch.
 
It's back to a 93, Chris Dring was right, shitty Mario C team could never make a real big game. Should have asked Arzest to help.
 
The trinity of quality has always been Mario, Zelda and Metroid. In year 2023 that trinity continues to be of highest quality.
 
Wouldn't it be a good time to think about a return of the Mario movie to the big cinema screens? ;D
 
Wild that what we're all expecting to be the Switch's last year might actually be stronger than it's first year.

Prime Remastered, Zelda, and now Mario. When was the last time a publisher had 3 games in one year hitting 93+ on metacritic? Personally, I'm ready to call this better than 2017.
 
Wild that what we're all expecting to be the Switch's last year might actually be stronger than it's first year.

Prime Remastered, Zelda, and now Mario. When was the last time a publisher had 3 games in one year hitting 93+ on metacritic? Personally, I'm ready to call this better than 2017.
you mean 4 90+ games

 
Wouldn't it be a good time to think about a return of the Mario movie to the big cinema screens? ;D
They should do that and tack on like 5 minutes of extra content to entice people, maybe a Mario short.

Holidays is slow and this year Hollywood films have been bombing more than most, and they could rake in some cash. At least 20-30m easily DOM.
 
0
No surprise there. My guess was around 93-95. Based on how wonderful heh the game’s marketing looks, mixed with how much people loved the demo and previews, this makes total sense. I’m so hyped for this
 
No more "89 curse"
No more "2D platformers don't break 90"
No more Fami home field skepticism
There is only Mario time
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top Bottom