I did that too lol. I always ditched Musse and I missed one of the guys (I think Elliot?), but felt like why not click yes on all of them here. I had Youtubed the ones I missed prior anyway so if there’s any bonus scenes here might as well see them.I do think it's kinda silly when the game lets you pick people you didn't actually bond with. As an example I had max bond with everyone but Emma from CS4, meaning I got a * and auto select for all of them, I just clicked Emma anyways because why not.
But yeah my CS4 save was stuck on my PS4 and I didn’t want to take whatever steps I had to to transfer the save data to my PS5. I seemingly still got the Cold Steel save data bonus so I think the PS5 version just lets you claim that for free?