Discussion Current Ranking of Mario Party 1 to 10 according to Mario Party Superstars Players (Vote for your own in the poll!)

[Djehuty]

Hi, I decided to check the online rankings for Mario Party 1 to 10 in Mario Party Superstars which is gathered from what players have said is their favourite Mario Party and I'd thought to share it with the members of Famiboards and hear your thoughts on what the players have picked. I will be periodically updating this OP with new data as time goes on if anything changes the next time I play.

As of December 20th 2022:​

1. Mario Party (N64)
2. Mario Party 2 (N64)
3. Mario Party 8 (Wii)
4. Mario Party 10 (Wii U)
5. Mario Party 3 (N64)
6. Mario Party 9 (Wii)
7. Mario Party 5 (GC)
8. Mario Party 4 (GC)
9. Mario Party 6 (GC)
10. Mario Party 7 (GC)

This list is Wack, not just for the wii u though, both here and there the n64 nostalgia is immense.

 

[Earthbounder]

I like your list, but to me people who think that Mario Party 5 and 1 are better than 7 are off their rocker.

Fair enough. In my mind those three are quite close, but 5 and 1 probably get the edge here because I had awesome multiplayer sessions with them. I know it's not exactly an objective criterion, but it might explain the order.

 

[Mekanos]

I always liked 3 the best. Great mini games and duel boards were fun. 2 is also really good but I think it suffers borrowing so many mini games from 1.

Outside of nostalgia for 1, 6 is maybe the only other MP is really like, though I’ve only played 1-6.