Imo, at least so far, it has these points against it:
- Iterative sequel that has the longest dev time of any 3D Zelda, thus raising expectations.
- Set in the same map as the first game whilst using the same engine.
- 3 teasers so far that haven't lessened any major criticisms of the first game (lack of real dungeons, more enemy variety, etc)
- Reviewers becoming more sensitive to performance issues.
I specified that it 'might' be the lowest rated 3D Zelda as I'm coping that they're keeping everything close to their chest