Site Event The Famiboards Game of the Year 2024 Celebration- (Final results have been posted. Please see threadmarks)

Fami Your Consideration
Best area
Living Memory (Final Fantasy XIV: Dawntrail)
Going to have to put this one under spoiler tags, because it has huge spoilers for Dawntrail and the game being an MMO with a sequential story lasting hundreds of hours through multiple expansions means it's difficult to put a statute of limitations on spoilers. Technically even the name of the area is a spoiler, though shorn of context I think it's fine to put here.

living-memory-in-final-fantasy-14-dawntrail-1.png

The fabled city of gold had been teased in the final part of Endwalker, and the hunt for it formed a major part of Dawntrail's scenario, so it's not surprise you eventually end up there for Dawntrail's finale. Living Memory is the pinnacle of the Alexandrian civilisation's advanced technology and research into the preservation of soul and memories; a perfected artificial afterlife for its citizens where they can while away eternity in peace and splendour as the Endless, under the loving gaze of their Queen, Sphene Til Alexandros XIV, whose bust adorns the central Meso Terminal towering over the zone.

And you have to destroy it. You don't have a choice, because Queen Sphene, herself long dead and now the AI avatar of the Meso Terminal, is hardcoded to keep Living Memory going at all costs. And the cost is to plunder the fundamental energy of creation - aether - from the entire FFXIV multiverse, which would lead to a multiversal collapse that would end with Living Memory starved of aether anyway and forced to shut down. The plan is multiversal genocide for no real benefit, and Sphene knows it, but her hardcoding forces her to rationalise it and spurn any attempt to reason with her.

The zone itself is peaceful and serene, even the sad, haunting theme is called 'Bygone Serenity'. As you travel through the zone to shut down the smaller subterminals before diving into the digital world of the main Meso Terminal to confront Sphene, the characters of your party get to meet or say a final goodbye to loved ones from their past. But these loved ones are also AI copies, because Living Memory is, as one character puts it, a twisted mausoleum. The Endless are the reconstituted memories of the dead, but without their souls, which have been scrubbed clean and put to other uses. And yet the interactions your party has with them are no less real for it even as it is recognised as a desecration of the dead.

And that's the power of the zone - the fundamental dichotomy between knowing this isn't real but the interactions the characters have still being meaningful. Each little subterminal has its own arc, which ends with the subterminal being shut off and the relevant characters disappearing as their data is deleted, at peace with your decision to end their existence to save yours. Again, no choice is presented here, you have to do it to proceed, but it's still devastating to see these characters, even if just AI copies, disappear, and I spent most of the zone sobbing, which no FFXIV zone has previously done. Previously, you were a hopebringer, now you're a destroyer.

After you defeat Sphene and shut down the Meso Terminal, Living Memory is finished. The gold sky gives way to the natural sky of the world, the buildings and technologies are a dull gray, dormant and unpowered, its inhabitants largely gone save a few stragglers, and Bygone Serenity is replaced with 'Echoes of Memory', a version of the theme that is distant, fuzzy, and constantly fades in and out to convey the enormity of what you have done. You could abuse New Game+ to 'restore' the zone... but shouldn't your actions, even with the best intentions, have consequences?

Congratulations, you've saved the multiverse. You monster.
 
okay, time to add for Best Soundtrack!

Best Soundtrack:
Crypt Custodian


All-around bangers from calm tunes to fight themes! Really amps up the atmosphere of the whole damn thing. A worthy nominee! The world is informed by the music and the whole thing is so lovely together. The fights are tense and exciting!



 
Fami Your Consideration
Best Surprise
No Case Should Remain Unsolved

images


Before I forget.

3h long. Recommended by every single Japanese adventure game creator (even though it's Korean). If you like visual novel/adventure games, this is THE GAME for you. If you're not but doesn't mind spending 3h of your life on a good story, this is also for you!
 
Last edited:
Game of the Year
Penny's Big Breakaway

Penny%27s_Big_Breakaway_box_art.jpg


Rightfully nominated in other categories already, I might be the only person it was a Game of the Year for but WOW WAS IT!

Astro Bot, I Platinumed. Echoes of Wisdom, I loved. But Penny's Big Breakaway? I GORGED ON.

100% completion in this game is NOT easy or straightforward, I've not gotten there, thank goodness the achievement list stops short of requiring all art!

But the swinging, jumping, the music. It's the game that's on been my mind all year. It takes a hot minute to get going but then it GOES. THIS is the Super Mario Galaxy of 2024.

GO PENNY!
 
I totally didn’t forget about this until the last minute

Best Platformer, Best Indie Game and Game of the Year: ANTONBLAST
GfltGecWQAAZXF0.jpg:large

I always kept forgetting about this game in the years leading to its release, but the wait was well worth it! I had the stupidest smile on my face the whole time playing this thing. It’s honestly one of the only games I can’t really find anything particularly bad about that wouldn’t be a personal nitpick at most (except the lag, but they patched that out later on)

Please play this game. If you like the Wario games, the 2D Crash games, or just like platformers in general, you will love this game. It’s $20! There’s a lot of worse ways to spend $20!

Also, shout out to one of the hardest moments in all of fiction. I hoped they would do The Thing here, and they did The Thing here, I legitimately stood up and cheered
SPOILER_20250125202239_1.jpg
 
Best Platformer
Animal Well


This is a weird one but I stand by it! The platforming in this game gets super strange and interesting, and it's absolutely worthy in a ton of weird, spoilery ways!
 
paging Here & There Along the Echoes gang

@VolcanicDynamo @VegiHam @chocolate_supra etc.

do we think either The Long Drink Bar & Implied Grill or Company Boat (Docked β€” The First Grave) could possibly qualify as best level?

@VegiHam said this about the first:

Me, on dates: Nooo don't recontextualize the lore by taking a recurring term and revealing it to be an oblique synonym for something else when approached in an alternative narrative reference frame; stripping away the artifice of twenty year old nostalgia and seamlessly shifting the tone into the mythic as a textual mirror of the shifting of the emotional content of the scene from memetic to dramatic your so sexy aha

and the second was a big fight!

(but I'm not gonna push it probably)
 
Fami Your Consideration
Best level/area/world
Final Fantasy VII Rebirth- "Gongaga"

all-gongaga-enemy-assess-locations-in-final-fantasy-7-rebirth.jpg


Another Final Fantasy Rebirth level? You bettcha! What I loved about this area, besides how gorgeous it was, is that it is a maze. You have to strategically pick the correct launching pad in order to reach certain areas. It isn't as simple as walking from point a to point b. You can legit get lost in this world, and I love it for that and more.
 
Best Puzzle Game
Animal Well


This game really makes you figure out a lot of wild stuff. It gives you so many strange tools and not a lot in the way of hints β€” but the design really invites you to stumble into the answers yourself in a way I found IMMENSELY satisfying.

Certain parts left me in complete shock when the wackiest idea I had actually worked, or when the world interacted with me in a way that seemed completely surreal, like it shouldn't be possible.

I know I've mentioned this game a lot, but it really is an all-timer.

Best Platformer
Animal Well


This is a weird one but I stand by it! The platforming in this game gets super strange and interesting, and it's absolutely worthy in a ton of weird, spoilery ways!


Ok Suswave. The rule is that a game can only be nominated for one genre category. My understanding is that Animal Well is more of a puzzle game, but I will let you make the call for which category you want to put it up for.

You have about an hour to decide. No pressure :)

Edit: I'll give you until first thing in the morning.
 
Last edited:
Ok Suswave. The rule is that a game can only be nominated for one genre category. My understanding is that Animal Well is more of a puzzle game, but I will let you make the call for which category you want to put it up for.

You have about an hour to decide. No pressure :)

Edit: I'll give you until first thing in the morning.
ohhh I didn't realize that certain categories were exclusionary

uhh

probably best puzzle game then? but a lot of the puzzles are very platforming-involved...
 
Voting is now live!
Thank you everyone for your participation to this point. We are now ready to start on the grand finale. The voting stage! The link below is the ballot. All categories are optional. Please make sure that you only vote for one game/character in each category.

The scoring will be the same as last year. Every category except for GOTY will be scored 3, 2, 1. GOTY will be scored 10, 9, 8... ect.


Have fun!
 
Thank you everyone for your participation to this point. We are now ready to start on the grand finale. The voting stage! The link below is the ballot. All categories are optional. Please make sure that you only vote for one game/character in each category.

The scoring will be the same as last year. Every category except for GOTY will be scored 3, 2, 1. GOTY will be scored 10, 9, 8... ect.


Have fun!
Thanks for your work here! This is great!

May the odds be in Rebirth's favor.
 
Submitted by ballot...

Feeling like a true member of the Video Games industry at this moment! Thank you to everyone that helped put this all together! I wish I had participated a little more in the discussion but (hopefully) with more time to play games this year and with the Nintendo Switch 2 launch, I will be able to contribute more in the 2025 Awards Nominations and Discussion process! :D
 
frankenstein doctor v monster moment with the screenshot chosen for Here & There Along the Echoes: A Famiboards Story – Chapter 2 of the Road Meat Saga (featuring @VolcanicDynamo from the Volcanic Dynamo series) – The Game of the Movie
 
clearly my mistake was in not creating 16:9 title cards for our Famiboards Games from the very start

rest in peace nomination mockup...

XYhquUv.png


how do I add these to backloggd or whatever people use these days
 
Last edited:
was there a personal goty list thread or something that I missed btw?

xghost does one every year!

 
I voted! Thanks Josh for putting this together!

Wild no first party Nintendo game got nominated for GOTY lol. Zelda was my fifth favorite last year.
I think this is a symptom of how Josh handles this, as in...you need to care enough to write down something about the game. And you can only nominate one game.

It takes a while and a lot of people won't nominate anything but it definitely gives for more passionate nominees so I quite enjoy this over the other formats.
 
I think this is a symptom of how Josh handles this, as in...you need to care enough to write down something about the game. And you can only nominate one game.

It takes a while and a lot of people won't nominate anything but it definitely gives for more passionate nominees so I quite enjoy this over the other formats.
Yeah I love the format. It’s a lot of fun and works very well for how small our forum is. I like we have room for less traditional nominations as a result too.
 


Back
Top Bottom