About two weeks ago I finished Persona 5 Royal for the first time. I'm working on my LttP for that. I had played the original Persona 5 back when it came out, but this PC release was my first time playing Royal. For those that remember my LttP threads from the other place, it will be in that style. I need to inquire if it's against the rules to post it both there and here though.
I currently went back to my playthrough of the PSP version of Persona 2: Eternal Punishment. I'd played the PS1 version before, but last year, the PSP version had a fan translation patch released. The PSP version has some extras, such as a special Tatsuya scenario and some quality of life changes, as well as the UI. For those that haven't heard it from me already, Eternal Punishment is my absolute favorite Persona game and is S-tier MegaTen to me. Innocent Sin's biggest problem was it's difficulty being stupidly easy, on top of negotiation being overly complicated, making it difficult to get cards and new Personas. It hardly mattered though because you could get through most of the game with the starter Personas. Eternal Punishment has this weird reputation of being difficult, when it really isn't. It just requires you to pay attention and go get the Personas you need for the situation you're struggling in. Sometimes those Personas may not be ones that are up to the level your party members are. For instance I have one that's almost 20 levels below my party's average level that I keep around just because it has Trafuri and Estoma, and isn't incredibly expensive to maintain.
Bosses have many interesting gimmicks. For instance there's one where it's a guy and his group of "SAT" (more like SWAT team) dudes, and all of them have sleep skills. Ideally, you want to bring at least one character that is resistant to sleep, but otherwise you might think the answer would be to just cure the sleep, right? Nope! If you try to do that, you'll soon realize it's unsustainable and you'll never get any damage in. You can't rely on fusion spells here either since your party will constantly be put to sleep, so you need to have some characters at least with individually powerful AoE magic to take out the "SAT" dudes first, and then the main guy is pretty easy from there. I know there's a particular one in the late game that has a gimmick where he heals 400+ HP automatically every turn, and that's not even his action. You have to just constantly be putting out Fusion Spell damage. Eternal Punishment is not a hard game, it's just one that requires your attention.
I will say the game does have some cryptic things, such as there's at least one Persona I know of that the game actually does not give a hint ANYWHERE that the method to get it exists. In Double Slash, there's a girl that will tell your Wang Long fortune if you tell her your birth month, but the method to tell her your birth month is a free text field. You tell her "HASTURCOMEFORTH" and back at Maya's office, there will be a package with a material card in it. Oddly enough, Hastur is a Persona that actually only appeared in two games: This one....and Persona 5 Royal!
For all those cryptic things though, there's stuff that feels like it might be cryptic, but really is there if you look for it. For example, in a dungeon early on, there's lots of spots of goop on the floor that damage you if you walk over it. Some of it is blocking certain paths. A rumor you can get is that a demon that appears in the dungeon is a clean freak. You learn that rumor, talk to that demon, and then she cleans the goop off the floor for you! Another example is there's a dungeon where you need a key to progress, but you don't see an immediate way to get it. Start talking to demons though and you'll learn that Rasputin has the key! Talk to Rasputin, get the key!
Anyway I could talk about Eternal Punishment all day and how genius this game is. You should play Innocent Sin first, but you're in for a treat once you get here. #PlayPersona2